During these cold winter months I warm my living room with a gas fireplace, and I've always been curious about how the heat moves through the room. So, since I have the tools (namely, my company's Slam Stick X Data Loggers), I figured I’d take some recordings, describe my set up, and share what I learned.
Setting up for the data acquisition was pretty simple. To minimize the file size, I really reduced the accelerometer data. I disabled the main accelerometer on the Slam Stick X’s, and I put the DC accelerometer at 12 Hz. I left the pressure data enabled because I thought it might show something interesting, and I left the control pad data at 10 Hz. If I ran this test again, I would probably turn off the pressure data and set the control pad data to 1 Hz, to reduce the data a bit.
The next step is to synchronize the devices. Synchronization sets the internal clocks on the devices to the same time, within a few milliseconds, so that we can roughly synchronize data across different devices. The synchronization will drift by up to a few seconds a day, but for a few hours of 10 Hz temperature data it works great.
To synchronize your devices, just:
- Plug all your devices into the computer
- Turn on Slam Stick Lab
- Go to Devices
- Click Set All Clocks
If you configure the devices after you do this, make sure that the ‘Set device clock on exit’ box on the bottom left of the configure screen is disabled, otherwise you’ll overwrite the synchronized time.
Once the Slam Sticks are configured, I put them around the living room. I placed everything in a direct line from the fireplace to the back window, as shown in the drawing. The fireplace itself is raised about 8 inches off the floor, and there was one Slam Stick on the floor in front of it, marked Fireplace. Above the fireplace is a nice old mantel that has about a 1 foot overhang. The Mantel Slam Stick went there. The Slam Stick marked Table went on the middle of the table towards the back of the room, past the couch. And the Window Slam Stick is on the far wall, 19 feet from the fireplace.
At 11:27am on Saturday, December 30th, 2017, I started the devices recording, and I let them record for almost 9 hours.
The fireplace has a few modes it can run in. It has a fan which can be on or off, and it has 5 heat levels. Generally, I have it either full on, with the heat at max and the fan on, or I have it on low with the fan off. To make things interesting, I did set the fireplace to a middle setting for a bit.
I let the devices record for almost 9 hours, and then went to grab the data. I ended up with a lot of data across multiple devices, so I thought it would be easiest to just export everything into CSV files, and deal with it in Excel. To do this, I copied all the IDE files off the Slam Stick, and onto my hard drive. Then I open up Slam Stick Lab, but instead of opening an IDE file, I open Tools->Batch IDE Exporter, add my IDE files into the Files to Process box, select .CSV for my format, and check the Include Column Headers, Use Absolute UTC Timestamps, and Use ISO Time Format boxes. Normally, the sample times are relative to the start of that device's acquisition, but checking the Absolute and ISO Format check boxes gives me sample times in seconds since the Unix Epoch of December 31, 1969, which lets me synchronize the data.
This graph displays the temperature in Fahrenheit. The fireplace temperature is in orange, the mantel is grey, the table is yellow, and the back window is in blue.
Throughout the test, the back window (blue) responds very sharply to the fireplace when the fan is on. In the later tests, I turned the fan off and bring the fire to low, and you can see the temperature slope right at the fireplace heat decreases slightly, but the slope at the back window is reduced most of all. My theory is that with the fan off, the hot air does not have the speed to move to the back wall without first getting soaked into the ambient air in the room.
When the fan is off and the heat is low, the obvious result is that everything heats up less quickly. The interesting thing is that if I turn the fire off after the fan was off, parts of the room keep heating up. What is happening is that the stone hearth around the fireplace, is soaking up more more heat with the fan off, and it keeps radiating heat for a while after the fire is off.
Around minute 70 there’s a weird 2 minute dip in temperature on the fireplace sensor. That’s completely my fault, my wife saw the Slam Stick laying by the fireplace, she did not know I started the test, so she picked it up with her, apparently, cold hands. Just moving the sensor for a moment can have a measurable impact.
At minute 345, there is dip in temperature that mostly impacts the fireplace and table Slam Sticks. This was when I came home and opened the door, which is right by the table. The fireplace Slam Stick is about 10 feet from the door, and I believe it was affected because the cold air was moving along the floor, so it really hit the low areas. There are other dips around minute 250 and 440, which should also be from the door opening.
For this project, the Slam Sticks were definitely overkill - there are much cheaper temperature sensors out there - but at the same time, if you have the tools you might as well use them, you never know what you might find.